Apartments vs Houses for Rent
A Complete 2025 Guide to Choosing the Right Rental for Your Lifestyle
12 min read
Updated: 2025
Apartment Rental
Advantages
- Lower cost: 20-40% cheaper on average
- Amenities included: Gym, pool, laundry
- Maintenance-free: Landlord handles repairs
- Security features: Secured entry, cameras
- Prime locations: Often near urban centers
- Flexibility: Easier to relocate
Drawbacks
- Limited space: Avg 900 sq ft
- Noise from neighbors: Shared walls
- No yard: Limited outdoor space
- Pet restrictions: Often stricter policies
- Parking fees: Additional monthly cost
House Rental
Advantages
- More space: Average 1,800+ sq ft
- Private yard: Outdoor living space
- No shared walls: More privacy, less noise
- Pet-friendly: More room for animals
- Storage: Garage, basement, attic
- Customization: Often more freedom
Drawbacks
- Higher cost: Rent + utilities higher
- Maintenance duties: Lawn, snow removal
- Higher deposits: Often 1-2 months
- Suburban locations: Longer commutes
- No amenities: No gym or pool
Cost Comparison Breakdown
| Cost Category | Apartment | House | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly Rent | $1,700 avg | $2,300 avg | +$600/month |
| Utilities | $100-$150 | $200-$350 | +$100-$200 |
| Security Deposit | 1 month | 1-2 months | +$0-$2,300 |
| Parking | $50-$200/month | Usually included | Savings |
| Renters Insurance | $15-$25/month | $20-$40/month | +$5-$15 |
| Annual Total | $22,000-$26,000 | $30,000-$42,000 | +$8,000-$16,000 |
Best Choice by Lifestyle
Singles & Young Professionals
Best choice:
ApartmentLower costs, urban locations, amenities, social atmosphere
Couples Without Kids
Best choice:
Either WorksDepends on priorities: savings vs space
Families with Children
Best choice:
HouseMore space, yard for play, better school districts
Frequently Asked Questions
Apartments are typically 20-40% cheaper than houses in the same area. The national average apartment rent is $1,700/month, while single-family home rentals average $2,100-$2,500/month. However, apartments may have additional fees (parking, pet rent, amenity fees) that close the gap. Total annual cost difference: approximately $8,000-$16,000 in favor of apartments.
Houses offer more space (average 1,800+ sq ft vs 900 sq ft for apartments), private yards, no shared walls or noise issues, more storage, often in-unit laundry, and more freedom for customization. They're ideal for families, pet owners, and those who value privacy.
First-time renters typically benefit from apartments due to lower costs, included maintenance, amenities like gyms and pools, and shorter lease options. Houses require more responsibility (lawn care, snow removal) and higher upfront costs but offer more independence.
Ready to Start Your Rental Search?
Create a state-compliant lease agreement for your new apartment or house.
Create Lease Agreement