NY
Updated 2025
Tenant-Friendly State
New York Eviction Laws 2025: What Happens If You Miss a Deadline?
Eviction in New York follows strict legal procedures. Missing a single deadline or serving improper notice can delay the process by weeks or result in case dismissal. This guide covers every timeline, penalty, and common mistake.
Choose Your Perspective
Non-Payment Notice
14 days
Lease Violation
10 days
Month-to-Month
30-90 days
Court Timeline
30-90 days
Legal Consequences of Eviction Violations in New York
Both landlords and tenants face serious consequences for mishandling the eviction process in New York. Here's what's at stake:
Landlord Violations
- Self-Help Eviction: Changing locks, removing doors, shutting off utilities, or removing tenant belongings without court order. Landlord may owe damages, punitive damages, and attorney fees.
- Improper Notice: Serving wrong notice type, wrong number of days, or improper service method. Case will be dismissed and landlord must restart the process.
- Retaliatory Eviction: Evicting because tenant complained about habitability issues or exercised legal rights. New York prohibits retaliatory evictions.
- Discriminatory Eviction: Evicting based on protected class (race, religion, familial status, disability). Federal and New York fair housing laws apply.
Tenant Consequences
- Eviction Judgment: Public record that appears in background checks, making future rentals difficult for 7+ years.
- Money Judgment: Court may award landlord unpaid rent, damages, court costs, and attorney fees.
- Forced Removal: Sheriff will physically remove tenant and belongings if tenant doesn't vacate after judgment.
- Credit Damage: Money judgments reported to credit bureaus can damage credit score significantly.
Timelines and Deadlines for New York Evictions
Missing any of these deadlines can delay eviction by weeks or result in case dismissal. New York law is strict about these timelines:
| Stage | New York Timeline | Consequence of Error |
|---|---|---|
| Non-Payment Notice | 14 days to pay or quit | Case dismissed if notice period not met |
| Lease Violation Notice | 10 days to cure or quit | Must restart with new notice if incorrect |
| Month-to-Month Termination | 30-90 days advance notice | Tenant not required to vacate until proper notice |
| File Court Case | After notice period expires | Filing early = case dismissed |
| Court Hearing | 30-90 days from filing | Varies by court backlog |
| Writ of Possession | Typically 24-72 hours after judgment | Sheriff schedules enforcement |
Critical: New York courts count notice days strictly. If the notice says 14 days, that means 14 days of calendar days, and filing even one day early can result in dismissal.
Penalties and Enforcement in New York
New York enforces eviction laws through courts. Here's what each party risks:
Illegal Eviction Penalties
Landlords who attempt self-help evictions in New York face:
- Actual Damages: Cost of hotel, moving expenses, damaged property
- Statutory Damages: May include multiple months' rent
- Punitive Damages: Court may award additional punishment
- Attorney Fees: Tenant's legal costs
- Criminal Charges: In severe cases, harassment or trespassing
Example Illegal Eviction Scenario
Landlord changes locks while tenant is at work. Tenant stays in hotel for 5 nights ($150/night = $750), loses work (2 days = $400), and hires lawyer ($1,500). Court awards: $750 + $400 + $1,500 + 3 months' rent ($4,500) = $7,150.
Eviction Judgment Consequences
Tenants with eviction judgments face:
- Public Record: Eviction shows in court records and background checks
- Rental Difficulty: Most landlords reject applicants with evictions
- Money Judgment: Owed rent, damages, fees may be collected through wage garnishment
- Credit Impact: Collections may appear on credit report
Sealing/Expungement
Some New York courts allow sealing of eviction records in certain circumstances, such as when tenant prevailed, case was dismissed, or tenant completed diversion program.
Common Eviction Mistakes in New York
These errors are the most frequent causes of eviction delays and dismissals in New York:
Landlord Mistakes
- Wrong Notice Type: Using pay-or-quit notice for lease violations, or vice versa. Must match the eviction reason.
- Wrong Notice Period: New York requires 14 days for non-payment. Using federal or other state timelines causes dismissal.
- Improper Service: Must serve notice according to New York rules (personal service, posting, mail). Skipping steps invalidates notice.
- Filing Too Early: Filing court case before notice period expires. Court will dismiss.
- Accepting Rent: Accepting full rent after serving notice may waive the eviction. Partial payment rules vary.
Tenant Mistakes
- Ignoring Notice: Hoping the problem goes away. Notice deadlines are strict and ignoring them leads to default judgment.
- Missing Court: Failing to appear at hearing results in automatic judgment for landlord.
- Not Documenting: Failing to keep copies of rent payments, communication, and property condition.
- Moving Without Settlement: Vacating without addressing money owed. Judgment can still be entered and collected.
- Not Seeking Help: New York has tenant rights organizations and legal aid that can help, often for free.
What Happens If This Is Handled Incorrectly?
Eviction cases that are mishandled can have serious long-term consequences. Here are common scenarios:
What happens: Tenant calls police. Landlord may be cited for trespassing or harassment. Tenant can sue for illegal eviction and recover actual damages, statutory penalties, punitive damages, and attorney fees. Meanwhile, tenant is entitled to remain in the property. Total cost to landlord can exceed $10,000+, and they still have to go through the proper eviction process.
What happens: Case is dismissed at hearing. Landlord has wasted filing fees ($100-300), service fees ($50-100), and 30-90 days of time. Must start completely over with new notice, adding another 14 days notice period plus 30-90 days court timeline. A 3-week eviction becomes a 2-month eviction.
What happens: Default judgment entered against tenant for full amount of rent owed, damages, court costs, and attorney fees. Eviction record appears in background check. Tenant may have wages garnished to pay judgment. Even if tenant had valid defenses (improper notice, habitability issues), they've waived them by not appearing.
What happens: Case is decided quickly by a judge who may have limited time. Tenant doesn't have time to gather evidence, find witnesses, or consult an attorney. In New York, tenants may have the right to request a jury trial or continuance, which can provide more time to prepare a defense or negotiate with the landlord.
New York Eviction FAQ
Quick answers to the most common eviction questions in New York:
NO In New York, landlords must go through the court system to legally evict a tenant. "Self-help" evictions (changing locks, shutting off utilities, removing belongings) are illegal in all 50 states and can result in the landlord paying significant damages to the tenant.
IT DEPENDS In New York, tenants often have the right to pay all past-due rent plus fees within the 14 days notice period to stop the eviction. Once a court case is filed, the landlord may still have to accept payment in some jurisdictions. However, for repeat non-payment or lease violations, the landlord may not be required to accept payment.
TENANT-FRIENDLY New York is considered a tenant-friendly state. This means longer notice periods, more tenant protections, and stricter requirements for landlords. The court timeline of 30-90 days is typically longer than landlord-friendly states.
IT DEPENDS For month-to-month tenancies, most New York landlords can terminate with 30-90 days notice without stating a reason. However, for fixed-term leases, landlords generally need cause (non-payment, lease violation, etc.). New York may have "just cause" protections in certain cities or for certain tenants. Discrimination and retaliation are never valid reasons for eviction.
YES If a judgment is entered against the tenant, the eviction becomes a public court record. Tenant screening services will find it in background checks, making it difficult to rent for 7+ years. Some New York courts allow sealing or expungement in limited circumstances.
YES New York does not have a statewide winter eviction moratorium. Evictions can proceed year-round. Some local jurisdictions may have temporary pauses during extreme weather. Emergency rental assistance programs may be available to help tenants avoid eviction.
Need New York Eviction Documents?
Create NY-compliant eviction notices and legal documents with our automated generator.