New York Security Deposit Laws for Landlords
- Maximum deposit
- 1 month rent (units under the rent control laws are outside this rule)
Source read · N.Y. Gen. Oblig. Law §§ 7-103, 7-108
- Return deadline
- 14 days
Source read · N.Y. Gen. Oblig. Law §§ 7-103, 7-108
Preview free$2.99/month or $19.99/year membershipCancel any time
On this page
New York deposit rules on file
- Interest Required?
- It depends
On facts this guide does not ask; see the rule as read below.
Source read · N.Y. Gen. Oblig. Law §§ 7-103, 7-108
- The rule as read
- Max 1 month's rent as a deposit or advance (units under the rent control laws are outside this rule). Within 14 days after the tenant moves out the landlord must return the deposit with an itemized statement of anything kept, or lose the right to keep any of it. Interest is owed only where the property has six or more family dwelling units: the deposit goes in an interest-bearing account and the tenant receives the interest, less 1% a year the landlord may keep (N.Y. Gen. Oblig. Law §§ 7-103, 7-108).
Deadlines for New York Landlords
The first two rows are the deadlines on file for New York, with their source above. The inspection rows are good practice, not New York law.
| Action | Deadline |
|---|---|
| Return Deposit | 14 days |
| Provide Itemized Statement | 14 days (same as return deadline) |
| Move-In Inspection | At or before move-in (good practice) |
| Move-Out Inspection | Within 48 hours of move-out (recommended) |
How a Deposit Dispute Usually Goes for a Landlord
General outline, not New York law. What a court can award, and when, is set by each state's statute. This guide gives a New York penalty only where the rule as read above states one.
Most deposit disputes a landlord faces turn on the same few points.
Where Landlords Go Wrong
- Overcharging: collecting more than the state allows, where it sets a limit.
- Late return: missing the state's return deadline. Under some statutes the landlord then loses the right to keep any part of the deposit.
- No itemization: keeping part of the deposit without a written, itemized list of deductions.
- Bad faith deductions: deducting for ordinary wear and tear, or for damage that did not happen.
- Where the money is held: some states say where a deposit must be kept; check the statute before mixing it with your own funds.
What a Tenant Usually Does Next
- Demand letter: a written request for the deposit, or for the itemized statement.
- Small claims court: the usual place for a deposit claim; each court sets its own limit.
- Civil court: for amounts above the small claims limit.
- Tenant rights organizations: may offer free help.
Security Deposit Mistakes to Avoid
General outline, not New York law.
These are the errors that most often turn into a deposit dispute, yours and your tenant's:
Your Mistakes
- No Written Inspection: Failing to document property condition at move-in makes it hard to prove the tenant caused damage.
- Missing the Deadline: The deadline on file for New York is 14 days. Put the date in your calendar the day the tenant leaves.
- Deducting Normal Wear: Charging for faded paint, worn carpet or minor scuffs is ordinary wear and tear, which deposit statutes generally do not let a landlord deduct.
- No Itemization: Sending a check for less than the full deposit without a written explanation of the deductions.
- Wrong Address: Mailing the deposit to the old address instead of the forwarding address the tenant gave.
Your Tenant's Mistakes
- No Move-In Photos: Without a record of existing damage, a tenant cannot dispute later claims.
- Not Providing an Address: You cannot return the deposit without a forwarding address.
- Leaving Early: Breaking the lease may let you keep the deposit for unpaid rent.
- Not Cleaning: Leaving the property dirty gives you a valid reason to deduct.
- Waiting Too Long: A tenant's claim has a time limit, which differs by state and court.
What Happens When a Deposit Is Mishandled
General outline, not New York law.
Security deposit disputes that are mishandled can escalate quickly. Here's how they usually go:
Your Checklist: Handling a New York Deposit
When you collect
- Maximum: 1 month rent (units under the rent control laws are outside this rule) (conditions and exceptions: the rule as read)
- Give the tenant a written receipt
- Document move-in condition in writing
- Take dated photographs of every room
When you deduct
- Damage only — not ordinary wear and tear
- Keep receipts for every repair
- Obtain more than one quote for larger work
- Itemize every deduction in writing
- Return the balance within 14 days
What Your New York Tenant Will Do at Move-Out
Before they move out
- Give written notice, as the lease requires
- Ask for a pre-move-out inspection, if you offer one
- Clean thoroughly and repair minor marks
- Replace anything missing from the unit
On the day and after
- Photograph every room with a timestamp
- Complete a move-out condition checklist
- Return all keys and ask you for a receipt
- Give you a forwarding address in writing
- Hold you to the deadline on file for New York: 14 days
If the deadline passes without the deposit or an itemized statement, a tenant's first step is normally a written demand letter.
New York Security Deposit FAQ
Quick answers for New York landlords:
Returning a New York Deposit?
Create a deposit return letter with an itemized list of deductions for New York, and preview it free.